PRAYAGRAJ: The Allahabad High Court has taken a strict stance against the unauthorized video recording of judicial proceedings on mobile phones, prohibiting litigants from carrying their devices inside courtrooms. The directive followed an incident in which a Varanasi resident was caught filming a hearing inside a courtroom. Although the individual was taken into custody, the court later closed the proceedings and ordered his release after he tendered an apology the next day. Authorities were also instructed to return his mobile phone only after deleting the recorded clips and resetting the device, while strictly barring him from uploading any courtroom footage to social media platforms.
Justice Vikram D. Chauhan noticed the man, identified as Raj Kulshrestha, recording court proceedings on his mobile phone during a hearing on November 19. An inquiry revealed that while Kulshrestha possessed an entry pass for the advocates’ chambers, he did not hold a valid pass authorizing entry into the courtroom. When questioned by the bench, he failed to explain the purpose behind filming the session. Court staff subsequently seized his phone, and an inspection uncovered at least three videos of the judicial proceedings stored on the device.
Viewing the breach seriously, the bench ordered that Kulshrestha be taken into custody and produced before the Chief Judicial Magistrate (CJM) of Prayagraj, with instructions to present him again before the High Court at 10 a.m. on November 20. The court clarified that he could apply for bail before the CJM by furnishing a personal bond and two sureties under prescribed conditions, subject to his mandatory appearance before the High Court the following morning.
Proceedings Closed After Apology
When Kulshrestha was produced before the bench in police custody on November 20, he apologized for his conduct. Accepting the apology, the court terminated the proceedings initiated against him and directed his release. The bench ordered that his mobile phone be handed back only after the courtroom videos were permanently deleted and the handset was factory reset. Furthermore, the court imposed a specific restriction prohibiting him from publishing or sharing any video of the court’s proceedings on social media.
Open Court Does Not Mean Free Broadcast
In its written order, the High Court underscored that while transparency and open hearings are vital pillars of the justice delivery system, the principle of an open court does not grant anyone the right to record and broadcast proceedings without permission. The bench asserted that the court possesses inherent powers to regulate its own procedures and maintain decorum inside the courtroom. Unauthorized recording or circulation of court hearings risks triggering a parallel media trial on social platforms, which can prejudice the parties involved before a final judicial verdict is delivered.
The order emphasized that courtrooms are not venues for public entertainment, as they adjudicate critical questions concerning personal liberty, fundamental rights, and private lives. Sharing sensitive case details or personal information on digital platforms can expose litigants and victims to social stigma, unnecessary harassment, and severe hardship. The court noted that it regularly hears sensitive matters involving child sexual abuse, personal liberty, elected representatives, and probes by agencies such as the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) and the Enforcement Directorate (ED), making confidentiality prior to final judgment essential to protect the rights of victims, accused persons, and other stakeholders.
Lawyers Directed to Brief Clients
To enforce the ban effectively, the High Court ruled that no litigant will be permitted to enter a courtroom carrying a mobile phone, clarifying that only advocates are exempt from this restriction. If a litigant is found possessing a mobile phone inside a courtroom, the concerned advocate will be held accountable for the lapse. Lawyers have been instructed to strictly advise their clients in advance not to bring mobile phones into courtrooms, and to leave their devices at their advocates’ offices or another secure location.
The Registrar General has been directed to display prominent notices regarding the prohibition at the High Court pass counter, and the Registrar (Protocol) has been tasked with ensuring that no litigant enters a courtroom without a valid entry pass. Entry passes issued by the registry will now explicitly state that no person other than advocates, particularly litigants, may carry mobile phones inside courtrooms. Reiterating the ban on November 20, the bench also referred the matter to a division bench currently hearing a related case on courtroom security.
