One Driver, 25 Cases; Another Man, 36: Suspected Insurance Fraud Uncovered

The420 Staff
5 Min Read


Follow us on Google News


Follow The420.in on Google News

A suspected motor accident compensation fraud has come under investigation in Gujarat after an insurance company found two individuals repeatedly named as drivers or vehicle owners in multiple accident claims. One individual appeared in 25 cases, while another figured in 36, raising allegations that false accident records were used to obtain compensation from insurance companies.

The discrepancies emerged during an investigation into a 2014 hit-and-run accident in which the driver responsible could not initially be identified.

How Did the Fraud Come to Light?

The case dates back to March 15, 2014, when Ramesh Baria was riding a scooter near the Hanuman temple in Atana Muvada village. He was allegedly killed in a hit-and-run accident, following which Kothamba police in Mahisagar district registered a case against an unidentified driver.

Baria’s family subsequently filed a compensation claim of ₹23.4 lakh before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (MACT) in Godhra. However, the proceedings were delayed because the driver responsible for the accident could not be identified.

FCRF Launches Certified Chief Risk Officer (CRO) Program for India’s Risk Leaders

Three years after the accident, Museb Idrish Samol, then aged 39, was identified as the driver of an Indica car bearing registration number GJ-06-CB-2498. Aslam Mahmad Chunchala, then aged 60, was listed as the vehicle’s owner.

The development prompted the insurance company to investigate the circumstances surrounding the claim.

What Did the Investigation Reveal?

The insurer’s investigation reportedly uncovered a pattern involving the same two individuals across several motor accident compensation cases registered at different police stations. Samol was found to have been identified as a driver in 25 MACT cases, while Chunchala appeared in 36 cases, including seven as a vehicle owner and 29 as a driver.

The investigation also raised questions about their driving licences. Despite their repeated appearances in accident proceedings, neither individual’s licence could be verified through the Regional Transport Office records described in the report. According to the complaint, Samol and Chunchala allegedly intervened in accident cases where the actual drivers could not be identified, allowing their names and vehicle details to be included in police records.

This allegedly enabled victims or their families to pursue compensation claims before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal.

How Were Compensation Claims Allegedly Manipulated?

The First Information Report alleges that the two individuals accepted responsibility for accidents involving unidentified drivers so that compensation proceedings could move forward.

Investigators suspect that the arrangement allowed compensation claims to be pursued using potentially fabricated accident details. The accused allegedly received between 5% and 10% of the compensation amount in return.

In the 2014 case, the complainant alleged that Samol was not driving the vehicle involved and that Chunchala’s car had been falsely connected to the accident.

An investigation report dated October 16, 2026, prompted the insurance company to approach police and seek criminal proceedings. The FIR invokes Sections 406, 420 and 120(B) of the Indian Penal Code, relating to criminal breach of trust, cheating and criminal conspiracy.

Were Similar Allegations Made Earlier?

The latest case is not the first time Chunchala has faced allegations concerning motor accident claims. On December 18, 2024, an insurance company representative filed a complaint with Godhra Taluka police alleging that Chunchala had falsely presented himself as the driver in an October 2015 accident involving a car that had struck his stationary vehicle.

That complaint concerned a compensation claim of ₹3 lakh. The insurer’s investigation also reportedly linked him to 24 accident cases registered across different police stations.

Police are now examining whether the suspected arrangement involved other individuals responsible for identifying accidents, arranging vehicles or preparing documents for compensation claims.

The allegations remain under investigation, and the full extent of any fraudulent compensation obtained has not been established.

About the author — Ayesha Aayat writes on cybercrime, digital safety, and emerging online threats. Her work focuses on public awareness, legal clarity, and technology-driven risks.