The Delhi High Court has ruled that an Aadhaar card alone cannot establish a worker’s date of birth in a retirement dispute.
Why Did the Employment Dispute Reach Court?
The ruling came as Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri upheld a labour court’s order directing a private firm to pay full back wages to a woman whose services had been illegally terminated in May 2017.
The woman claimed she had worked as a finishing worker since 1981. She alleged that the management refused to pay revised wages following an increase in minimum wages for skilled workers announced by the Delhi government in March 2017. Her employment was allegedly terminated on May 20, 2017, when she sought payment of her April wages. She subsequently approached the labour court seeking reinstatement and full back wages. The employer disputed her allegations, maintaining that she had reached the retirement age of 58 in 2017.
FCRF Launches Certified Chief Risk Officer (CRO) Program for India’s Risk Leaders
What Did the Employer Claim?
The company argued that the woman’s Aadhaar card recorded her birth year as 1959, making her eligible for retirement under the factory’s prevailing practice. It also claimed that she had voluntarily resigned, accepted retirement and received her outstanding dues.
However, the labour court examined the company’s Employees’ State Insurance Corporation (ESIC) records, which recorded her date of birth as May 20, 1960. These details had been furnished by the management itself when she was registered in June 2010. The labour court found that the employer had failed to establish resignation, voluntary retirement or medical incapacity. It consequently held that her termination was illegal and unjustified.
Why Did the High Court Reject Aadhaar as Evidence?
Justice Ohri observed that the company relied exclusively on the Aadhaar card without producing independent documentary evidence establishing the woman’s date of birth. The court noted that the Aadhaar card had been received by the management in March 2017, just two months before her employment ended. In contrast, the ESIC records were prepared years earlier, when no apparent dispute existed between the parties.
The court found that the employer could not disregard its own earlier records and subsequently rely on a different birth year to justify ending the woman’s employment one year earlier.
What Did the Court Decide on Back Wages?
The High Court upheld the labour court’s findings, observing that they were supported by evidence and did not warrant judicial interference. It further held that the employer had failed to prove either voluntary resignation or retirement. Since the woman had not attained the applicable retirement age, terminating her services without complying with Section 25F of the Industrial Disputes Act was illegal.
The decision maintained the direction requiring the employer to pay full back wages, reinforcing the importance of reliable employment records when determining retirement eligibility.
The420 Insight
The judgment highlights the importance of maintaining consistent employee records. Employers cannot rely solely on Aadhaar details to establish retirement eligibility when earlier official employment records indicate a different date of birth.
