German software giant SAP is facing fresh criticism over the conditions attached to its artificial intelligence tools, with a major customer group warning that smaller businesses could struggle to access the technology without making substantial cloud spending commitments.
Thomas Henzler, the newly appointed chairman of the German-speaking SAP User Group (DSAG), raised concerns about the company’s commercial requirements in an interview published on November 18.
The warning comes months after SAP announced that businesses operating older software systems could access selected AI features without immediately moving their entire operations to the cloud.
However, Henzler argued that the financial conditions could make this arrangement practical mainly for larger companies with multiple business software systems.
SAP has disputed that interpretation, insisting that smaller customers operating a single system can also qualify if they meet the necessary commercial and technical requirements.
FCRF Launches Certified Chief Risk Officer (CRO) Program for India’s Risk Leaders
Why Smaller Businesses Could Face Difficult Choices
SAP provides enterprise resource planning software, commonly called ERP, which companies use to manage finance, inventory, procurement, payroll and other everyday operations.
Thousands of organisations continue to operate older SAP systems on their own servers instead of moving their information and applications to cloud platforms.
SAP has been encouraging these customers to modernise through its RISE with SAP programme, which combines cloud software subscriptions with business transformation services.
In May 2026, the company announced that eligible customers still using older systems could access selected Joule AI capabilities while preparing for migration.
The arrangement appeared to offer businesses a way to adopt artificial intelligence without immediately replacing their existing infrastructure.
However, Henzler said the commercial conditions could create difficulties for smaller organisations.
Under SAP’s published eligibility framework, qualifying customers generally need cloud subscription commitments equivalent to at least 50% of their existing annual on-premises maintenance fees, subject to their contract arrangements.
Henzler argued that businesses operating only one older ERP system might find this difficult to achieve without converting substantial parts of their existing software spending into cloud subscriptions.
Larger enterprises operating several systems could have greater flexibility to migrate them gradually.
SAP rejected the suggestion that eligibility depends on how many systems a customer operates.
The company said customers could access supported AI capabilities while modernising their infrastructure, provided they meet the applicable requirements.
What Are Joule AI And On-Premises Systems?
SAP’s Joule is an artificial intelligence assistant designed to help employees perform business tasks using information stored in company software.
For example, an employee could use an AI assistant to retrieve financial information, examine business records or help complete routine administrative work.
Joule Studio allows organisations to build AI agents that can automate selected business processes.
An AI agent is software designed to carry out certain tasks with limited human intervention, rather than simply answering questions.
An on-premises system, meanwhile, means software operated on servers controlled by the company itself.
A cloud system runs on computing infrastructure managed by a service provider, allowing businesses to access applications and information remotely.
SAP’s older ERP Central Component, or ECC, is one example of an on-premises system. Its newer S/4HANA software can also operate in different deployment arrangements.
Connecting these older systems to AI services could allow businesses to modernise gradually while continuing to use existing software.
However, access to the technology depends not only on technical compatibility but also on licensing and commercial agreements.
Earlier Cloud Disputes Add Pressure On SAP
SAP’s latest disagreement follows years of debate over how quickly customers should move from traditional software installations to subscription-based cloud services.
In July 2023, SAP indicated that its newest innovations would primarily be delivered through cloud offerings.
That approach drew criticism from customers concerned about migration costs, customised software and the disruption involved in changing critical business systems.
The company softened its position in May 2026 by offering qualifying legacy customers access to selected AI features during their transition.
Separate competition concerns also emerged in Europe. In July 2026, European regulators accepted commitments from SAP intended to make switching and support arrangements easier for customers.
The latest dispute is different. It concerns the affordability and commercial conditions of AI access, rather than an established competition-law violation.
For Indian businesses using SAP, the debate is relevant because software migration can involve considerable spending, technical changes and operational planning.
Companies considering Joule will need to evaluate whether the benefits of automation justify the subscription commitments required for access.
For now, SAP maintains that its approach supports customers of different sizes, while DSAG continues seeking more flexible terms.
The disagreement leaves a central question unresolved: whether expanding AI availability will translate into affordable access for businesses that are not yet ready for major cloud investments.
If your business uses SAP, request written clarification of Joule eligibility, cloud subscription requirements and total migration costs before signing a new agreement. Compare the projected benefits of AI automation with the long-term financial commitment.
