The State Bank of India has been ordered to pay Rs 15,000 in compensation to a 19-year-old YouTuber after freezing his savings account over three transactions worth Rs 1,000 each made to promote his YouTube channel. Ruling on a case in which the account remained frozen for nearly three years, the Jodhpur District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission-I termed the bank’s action a deficiency in service and directed it to reactivate the account. The commission noted that the bank failed to prove that the transactions were illegal or that the complainant was involved in any unlawful activity.
The case pertains to Arjun, a resident of Newra in Osian tehsil of Jodhpur district. He had opened a savings account at the Newra Road branch of the State Bank of India to receive earnings from his YouTube channel. According to Arjun, on May 19, 2023, he made three payments of Rs 1,000 each through Google to promote his channel. Following these transactions, the bank deemed them suspicious and froze his account, preventing him from withdrawing his own funds.
Bank Cites Suspicious Transactions
In its submission before the commission, the bank argued that Arjun had opened the savings account under the student category. According to SBI, its off-site transaction monitoring system flagged certain transactions in the account as suspicious, prompting the bank to seek an explanation from the account holder.
SBI stated that the account was placed on hold on May 31, 2023, after it did not receive a satisfactory response. The bank maintained that its action was taken as part of routine monitoring for suspicious financial activities.
However, Arjun challenged the bank’s decision before the consumer commission, calling it unjustified. He stated that the payments were routine commercial transactions carried out to promote his YouTube channel, yet the bank froze his entire savings account without sufficient grounds and deprived him of access to his own money.
Bank Fails to Provide Proof of Illegal Transactions
During the hearing, a bench comprising District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission-I President Rajkumar Sudhar and member Dilshad Ali examined the bank’s arguments and the available records. The commission observed that SBI could not present adequate evidence to establish that the three transactions made through Google were illegal or that Arjun was engaged in any unlawful activity.
The commission also noted that the bank failed to prove that notices seeking an explanation were properly delivered to the complainant. Keeping an account frozen for an extended period merely on suspicion of irregular transactions cannot be considered justified, the bench observed.
Declaring the bank’s conduct a deficiency in service, the commission clarified that banking institutions must have sufficient grounds and follow due procedure before restricting a customer’s account.
Order to Reactivate Account Within Two Months
The commission directed SBI to complete Arjun’s KYC formalities and lift the freeze on his account within two months so that he can resume normal banking operations.
In addition, the bank was ordered to pay Rs 10,000 toward mental harassment and Rs 5,000 as litigation expenses, bringing the total compensation to Rs 15,000.
The ruling carries significance for banking institutions, underlining that freezing customer accounts under the guise of monitoring suspicious transactions requires adherence to due process and substantial grounds. The order makes it clear that banks must also be prepared to produce evidence supporting their regulatory or administrative actions.
