Himachal Pradesh High Court Draws Legal Line Between AI Content and Forgery

The420 Staff
6 Min Read


Follow us on Google News


Follow The420.in on Google News

The Himachal Pradesh High Court has quashed an FIR registered over allegedly defamatory AI-generated videos and photographs circulated on Facebook, holding that the mere creation or circulation of such material does not constitute forgery unless the essential ingredients of the offence are established.

Justice Rakesh Kainthla ruled that police cannot invoke unrelated cognisable offences to investigate allegations of defamation, which is classified as a non-cognisable offence under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS).

What Was the Case Before the High Court?

The proceedings arose from a complaint filed by a man who alleged that two individuals had circulated AI-generated videos and photographs on Facebook containing defamatory material against him and his family.

The disputed content allegedly depicted the complainant promoting a scheme called “Our Family, a Happy Family” while making his wife, nephew, relatives and friends its beneficiaries.

Other posts allegedly showed the complainant collecting money and fleeing with it. The material also claimed that his sister-in-law had secured government employment and that his brother had become a director.

Following the complaint, Ghumarwin police in Bilaspur district registered an FIR on September 2 under Sections 351(2), 356(2) and 336(4) of the BNS, relating to criminal intimidation, defamation and forgery intended to harm reputation.

Why Did the Court Reject the Forgery Allegation?

The High Court examined whether the allegations disclosed the legal ingredients necessary to constitute forgery under Section 336(4) of the BNS.

Justice Kainthla observed that the FIR did not allege that the disputed videos or photographs had been falsely represented as creations of another person, altered without lawful authority after their creation, or obtained through deception from someone incapable of understanding their contents. The court held that merely alleging that material contained false information was insufficient to establish forgery.

The ruling distinguished between allegedly defamatory content and the creation of a false document or electronic record satisfying the statutory requirements of forgery.

Consequently, the presence of AI-generated content did not, by itself, justify invoking the forgery provision.

Can Police Investigate Defamation Through an FIR?

The court clarified that defamation under Section 356(2) of the BNS is a non-cognisable offence and ordinarily requires a complaint before the competent magistrate.

Police cannot investigate such an offence through the registration of an FIR unless the applicable legal requirements are satisfied. Justice Kainthla held that registering an FIR for cognisable offences not disclosed by the allegations, merely to investigate a private dispute involving a non-cognisable offence, would defeat the legislative safeguards governing police investigations.

The court therefore rejected the attempt to sustain the investigation by invoking additional criminal provisions.

What Did the Police Investigation Reveal?

Following registration of the FIR, police seized mobile phones and sent the disputed videos and photographs to the state forensic science laboratory.

Investigators also contacted Facebook to identify the accounts from which the material had been uploaded. The state argued that the AI-generated material constituted false documents and could spread hatred.

However, the High Court found that the allegations did not adequately explain how the content could cause public fear or alarm, or induce the commission of an offence against the state or public tranquillity, as required under Section 353(1)(b) of the BNS.

Why Was the FIR Quashed?

The court concluded that the allegations did not establish the necessary ingredients of the cognisable offences invoked by police.

It further held that the non-cognisable offence of defamation could not be investigated by adding provisions that were not supported by the complaint. Accordingly, the High Court quashed the FIR and all consequential proceedings arising from it.

The decision reinforces the requirement that criminal allegations involving digital content must satisfy the specific statutory elements of the offences invoked.

What Does the Judgment Mean for AI-Generated Content?

The ruling clarifies that AI-generated videos and photographs are not automatically treated as forged material merely because they allegedly contain false or defamatory information.

Criminal liability depends on whether the conduct satisfies the legal ingredients of the relevant offence.

The judgment does not provide blanket protection for AI-generated content. Rather, it requires investigating authorities to distinguish between allegations of defamation, forgery and other criminal offences before initiating proceedings under the applicable provisions of the BNS.

The420 Insight

The judgment draws an important legal distinction between false digital content and forgery. While AI-generated material may give rise to legal complaints, its creation or circulation alone does not establish every criminal offence alleged against it. Police must identify the specific statutory violation and follow the prescribed procedure before proceeding with an investigation.