​Railways Ordered to Pay ₹25,000 After RAC Ticket Was Downgraded to Waiting List Without Notice

Rajesh Rai
5 Min Read


Follow us on Google News


Follow The420.in on Google News

A consumer commission in Kerala has ordered the railway administration to pay ₹25,000 in compensation and litigation costs to a passenger whose Reservation Against Cancellation (RAC) ticket was downgraded to a waiting list and subsequently cancelled without prior notice. Holding the railways guilty of deficiency in service and unfair trade practice, the Malappuram District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission absolved the Indian Railway Catering and Tourism Corporation (IRCTC) of any liability in the matter.

​The complainant, Yadukrishnan C, a law student at KC Law College in Mumbai, had booked a ticket via IRCTC on Train No. 16345, Netravati Express, from Lokmanya Tilak Terminus to Kayamkulam Junction in Kerala for an urgent journey. At the time of booking, his ticket stood at Waiting List-77, which later progressed to RAC-44. However, after the reservation chart was prepared, the status was altered to Waiting List-1 and automatically cancelled by the railway administration. The passenger stated that he had neither cancelled the ticket himself nor received any prior intimation regarding the downgrade or cancellation.

​Passenger Forced to Buy Costlier Fresh Ticket

​Yadukrishnan had paid ₹1,819, inclusive of GST, for the original booking. Following the automatic cancellation, the railways refunded ₹1,730 after deducting ₹65 as clerkage charges. Deprived of his original booking at the last minute, he was forced to purchase a fresh ticket under the current availability quota on the same Netravati Express on September 9, 2024, spending ₹2,339 inclusive of GST.

​In his complaint before the commission, the passenger argued that since seats were available on the same train even after the chart was prepared, he could have been accommodated on his original ticket. He challenged the arbitrary downgrading of his ticket status, the cancellation without notice, and the deduction of clerkage fees from his refund.

​Railways Cite Coach Replacement, RTI Raises Questions

​During the proceedings, the railway administration contended that operational requirements necessitated replacing a Third AC (3A) coach with a Third AC Economy (3E) coach. This substitution required reallocating seats and reservations for previously booked passengers, affecting the ticket status of some travellers. The railways also argued that an RAC status is provisional and does not guarantee a confirmed berth, while questioning the jurisdiction of the consumer commission over the Railway Claims Tribunal.

​IRCTC, meanwhile, submitted that its role is restricted to providing an online booking platform, while seat allocation, chart preparation, and automatic cancellations fall entirely under the control of the railways. It noted that the ₹65 clerkage fee was also deducted by the railway administration.

​Examining the ticket records, email correspondence, and replies obtained under the Right to Information (RTI) Act, the commission found no clear railway policy permitting the downgrade of a ticket from RAC-44 to Waiting List-1. While the railways admitted that the status changed after the 3A coach was replaced with a 3E coach, they failed to explain why downgrading and cancelling the ticket was necessary, or why the passenger was not informed beforehand.

​Compensation Ordered Within 45 Days

​A bench comprising commission president Mohandasan K and members Preethi Sivaraman C and Mohammed Ismayil CV ruled that downgrading an RAC ticket to a waiting list without sufficient explanation, cancelling it automatically, and deducting ₹65 amounted to deficiency in service and unfair trade practice.

​The commission directed the railways to pay ₹20,000 as compensation for mental agony and physical hardship, along with ₹5,000 toward litigation expenses. The Additional General Manager of Central Railway has been given 45 days to comply with the order, failing which the total amount of ₹25,000 will carry an annual interest of nine percent from the date of the order until realization.