The central government has accused the Indian unit of Chinese smartphone maker Xiaomi and its former contract manufacturer Flex of withholding complete details of technical royalty payment agreements from customs authorities. In a filing submitted to the Supreme Court, the government stated that Xiaomi provided the relevant licensing agreements only after an investigation was initiated. The dispute exposes Xiaomi India to a potential tax liability and penalty exceeding $150 million, or more than Rs 1,350 crore.
Dispute Over Royalty Valuation and Customs Duty
The case centers on royalty payments made by Xiaomi to its partners for the use of technology and intellectual property. Indian tax authorities contend that these payments should have been included when determining the value of imported mobile phone components. Officials allege that excluding the royalty sums from the declared value of imported parts resulted in a lower customs duty assessment.
Xiaomi has contested this enforcement action. In January, the company filed an appeal in the Supreme Court challenging a customs tribunal ruling. The tribunal had held that during the three-year period prior to 2020, Xiaomi failed to include royalty payments made to technical partners in the valuation of imported handset components, leading to a shortfall in customs duty payments.
Xiaomi maintains that the mobile phone parts were imported directly by its contract manufacturers. According to the company, the royalty payments of two to five percent paid to technical partners fell under a separate arrangement and should not be factored into customs duty calculations. Xiaomi argues that the import of components and the payment of technical licensing fees must be treated as distinct transactions.
In its response filed before the Supreme Court on September 21, the central government urged the court to dismiss Xiaomi’s plea. The government asserted that Xiaomi was fully aware of the licensing arrangements governing the royalty payments but failed to make the required disclosures to customs officials until after the inquiry began, forming the basis for recovering unpaid duties and penalties.
Former Contract Manufacturer Flex Faces Scrutiny
Xiaomi’s former contract manufacturer, Flex, is also contesting findings in the same matter. Flextronics Technologies India, the local subsidiary of the U.S.-listed firm, petitioned the Supreme Court earlier this year to expunge remarks made by the tax tribunal. The tribunal had alleged that the contract manufacturer willingly participated in structuring layered transactions.
Flex has denied the allegations, maintaining that it did not assist Xiaomi in undervaluing imported components in India and should not be held liable for any irregularities in import valuation.
The government has opposed Flex’s petition as well. In a separate response filed on September 11, tax authorities stated that the company failed to produce original contracts and actual business arrangements before the customs department, which officials said were necessary to determine accurate import valuations. Flex did not respond to queries seeking comment on the matter.
Broader Impact on Contract Manufacturing Sector
The legal battle is being closely watched beyond Xiaomi, as contract manufacturing is expanding rapidly in India with major investments from companies such as Foxconn, Jabil, and Tata Electronics. Legal and industry observers note that the Supreme Court’s ruling could set an important precedent on how technical licenses, royalties, and import valuations are assessed between brands and their manufacturing partners.
Experts suggest that if the government’s position is upheld, similar tax scrutiny could extend to pharmaceutical, automotive, and other manufacturing sectors that rely on third-party production partners. However, the government clarified in its court submission that its case does not seek to invalidate all contract manufacturing models, focusing instead on specific transactions and alleged incomplete disclosures by Xiaomi and Flex.
Xiaomi, which holds roughly a 12 percent share of India’s smartphone market, is already navigating multiple regulatory challenges, including a proposed probe by the Serious Fraud Investigation Office into alleged irregularities in its business model. The company has not commented on that proposed inquiry. The outcome of the pending Supreme Court royalty dispute is expected to carry significant implications both for Xiaomi’s financial liability and for India’s broader contract manufacturing ecosystem.
