​Cyber Fraud Accused Cannot Dictate Where Victims File FIRs, Rules Supreme Court

Rajesh Rai
5 Min Read


Follow us on Google News


Follow The420.in on Google News

Taking a firm stance on cyber fraud and organised economic offences, the Supreme Court has made it clear that an accused person cannot dictate where victims file First Information Reports (FIRs). The court also ruled that an accused cannot stop police forces in different states from investigating alleged offences that fall within their respective jurisdictions. Emphasising that the law must be enforced with full strictness to tackle organised cybercrime, the court held that relief cannot be granted merely because investigations in different states share certain similarities.

​A bench comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V. Mohana made these observations on Friday while hearing a petition filed by Bhumi Utpalbhai Patel. The petitioner had sought relief in connection with criminal cases registered against her in Gujarat and Haryana. These cases pertain to an alleged investment fraud involving the sale of virtual cloud space.

​Supreme Court Refuses to Club FIRs Across States

​During the hearing, counsel for the petitioner requested the court to club the FIRs registered in Gujarat and Haryana. However, the Supreme Court declined to accept the plea. The bench clarified that mere similarities in investigations across different states do not form a valid ground to consolidate all FIRs or extend relief to the accused.

​The court stated that no benefit can be extended to an accused on the basis of overlapping aspects in separate probes. It observed that deciding how to proceed with the investigation of different cases falls squarely within the domain of the investigating agencies. At the same time, the court clarified that the petitioner is at liberty to approach the jurisdictional High Court to seek the consolidation of cases registered within a single state.

​Victims’ Right to File Complaints Remains Paramount

​Justice Joymalya Bagchi made sharp observations during the proceedings in response to the petitioner’s plea for relief. He stated that an accused cannot determine the location where aggrieved victims choose to lodge their complaints. Similarly, an accused cannot restrain police in different states from probing alleged offences committed within their territorial jurisdiction.

​The bench’s remarks underscored that when cyber offences span across multiple states, an accused cannot be given the convenience of bringing all cases under one roof solely on account of investigative similarities. In each instance, the concerned police and investigating agencies hold the legal authority to act within their statutory powers.

​No Leniency for Organised Cybercrime

​Justice Bagchi reiterated that the court would not confer any advantage on an accused simply because separate probes share common features, noting that such operational decisions belong to the investigating agencies. When the petitioner’s side urged the bench to adopt a lenient approach, the court made it clear that it was not inclined to grant any concession.

​Delivering a stern message, Justice Bagchi stated that no leniency can be shown in such matters and that the law must be enforced with full rigour. Taking note of the gravity of organised cybercrime, the court also indicated its reluctance to interfere unnecessarily in the ongoing investigative process.

​According to court records, criminal cases against the petitioner are pending before lower courts in Gandhinagar, Gujarat, and Faridabad, Haryana. The records further note that Patel had surrendered, and a custody certificate was placed before the court. She has been lodged in judicial custody as an undertrial prisoner for five months and five days, and is currently housed in the Ahmedabad Central Jail in Gujarat. While refusing to club the Gujarat and Haryana FIRs, the Supreme Court left it open for her to move the concerned High Court for clubbing the cases within Gujarat. Legal observers view the court’s remarks as significant for inter-state cyber fraud cases, where victims and financial transactions are often spread across multiple jurisdictions.