​Use of UPI PIN alone not proof of customer consent, rules Telangana consumer commission

Rajesh Rai
4 Min Read


Follow us on Google News


Follow The420.in on Google News

HYDERABAD: The Telangana State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission has directed the State Bank of India (SBI) to refund Rs 55,000 stolen from a woman’s account in a UPI fraud case and pay an additional Rs 30,000 towards compensation and litigation costs, bringing the total payout to Rs 85,000. In a significant ruling on banking accountability in digital fraud, the commission observed that the mere use of a UPI PIN or authentication mechanism does not by itself prove that the account holder authorized the transaction.

​The case pertains to the bank account of a 44-year-old woman from Telangana. According to her complaint, Rs 55,000 was debited from her SBI account through UPI on November 3, 2022. She maintained that she neither executed the transaction nor permitted anyone else to do so, and denied sharing her confidential banking credentials with anyone.

​Cyber Fraud Reported Within Three Working Days

​Upon discovering the unauthorized withdrawal, the woman lodged a complaint on the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal on November 6, 2022. The following day, on November 7, she submitted a written complaint to the concerned SBI branch. Although the bank acknowledged her complaint, it allegedly failed to refund the debited amount.

​She subsequently approached police officials, leading to the registration of an FIR on December 31, 2024. With the bank declining to return her money, she moved the consumer commission, where advocate N Poornachandra represented her. During the proceedings, SBI contended that the disputed transaction was completed using a UPI PIN alongside mobile and SIM-binding authentication. Arguing that such a transfer was impossible without completing required security protocols, the bank claimed the customer had either approved the payment or compromised her credentials, while also alleging a delay in reporting the incident.

​UPI PIN Alone Not Proof of Consent

​After hearing both sides, a bench comprising Commission President Mamidi Christopher and members S Sandhya Rani and K Venkateswarlu passed the order on November 10. The commission held that the use of a UPI PIN or any authentication system does not conclusively establish that the customer authorized the transaction or negligently shared sensitive details. Banks must produce concrete facts and evidence to prove that the account holder actually consented to the transfer.

​The bench emphasized that a service provider and consumer relationship exists between a bank and its account holder. Therefore, the bank is obligated to address customer grievances appropriately and ensure compliance with prescribed security standards in banking services.

​Timely Complaint and Total Compensation Ordered

​Examining the timeline of the complaint, the commission noted that the fraud occurred on November 3, 2022, and the woman reported it to the bank on November 7. Excluding Sunday, November 6, from the calculation of working days, the commission held that November 7 fell within the stipulated three-working-day reporting window.

​Failing to refund the disputed sum despite timely reporting amounted to deficiency in service, especially as there was insufficient evidence on record to prove that the woman carried out the transaction or leaked her credentials. Consequently, the commission ordered SBI to refund the principal amount of Rs 55,000, along with Rs 20,000 as compensation for deficiency in service and Rs 10,000 towards litigation expenses.