NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court has raised serious questions over the functioning of its own registry after an appeal filed by the Enforcement Directorate (ED) failed to be listed for effective hearing for nearly three years. On Friday, a bench headed by Chief Justice Surya Kant, alongside Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana, expressed strong displeasure over the prolonged delay and sought an explanation from the registry. Justice Bagchi termed the situation “nothing but institutional lethargy.”
The appeal pertains to anticipatory bail granted to businessman Raman Singhal, alias Raman Singhla, in a money laundering case. The ED had challenged a January 2023 order of the Punjab and Haryana High Court. Although the agency filed its petition in May 2023 and the apex court issued a notice in September 2023, the matter could not be taken up for effective hearing for almost three years despite repeated directions to relist it for final disposal.
Chief Justice Questions Three-Year Listing Gap
During the hearing, Chief Justice Surya Kant questioned the registry’s lapse, asking why the case had not come up for hearing even after September 2023, September 2024, September 2025, and September 2026 had passed. When a counsel suggested that the bench might not have been available, the Chief Justice firmly clarified that all benches were available.
Remarking on the administrative failure, Justice Bagchi said, “This is nothing but institutional lethargy.” The Chief Justice subsequently directed the registry to explain why the appeal was not listed for hearing despite previous judicial orders.
Allegations in the Rs 155.21 Crore Bank Fraud Case
The ED’s appeal stemmed from an alleged Rs 155.21 crore bank fraud involving Mahesh Timbers Private Limited. The agency alleged that the company fraudulently enhanced the limits of Foreign Letters of Credit (FLCs) and diverted the proceeds to a Singapore-based firm, Amazon Exports Pte Limited. Raman Singhal was a director of the Singapore entity, and the ED claimed these transactions caused a loss of Rs 155.21 crore to the bank, prompting a prosecution complaint against Singhal and other accused under money laundering charges.
On January 30, 2023, the Punjab and Haryana High Court had granted anticipatory bail to Singhal, noting that the ED had already filed its prosecution complaint and had stated that he could not be arrested at that stage without a warrant from the trial court. During Friday’s hearing, senior advocate Siddharth Dave, appearing for Singhal, expressed surprise over the delay, saying he had never witnessed such a situation in his Supreme Court practice since 1990. Senior advocate Zoheb Hossain, representing the ED, remarked that Dave perhaps had not worked in the registry, to which Dave replied that his intention was only to point out how unusual the delay was.
ED Appeal Disposed Of as Trial Progresses
The bench was informed during the proceedings that the trial in the case has already commenced, with the statements of eight witnesses recorded so far. Taking note of the advanced stage of the trial, the Supreme Court declined to entertain the ED’s appeal further and disposed of the petition.
Responding to a request from the ED’s counsel that the impugned High Court order not be treated as a precedent in future cases, the Supreme Court clarified that the High Court ruling shall neither serve as a precedent in any other matter nor have any bearing on the outcome of the ongoing trial. While denying relief to the ED at this stage, the court maintained its demand for accountability from the registry over the nearly three-year delay.
