​New York District Court Seeks Cooperation from Delhi Courts in Lawsuit Against Doval, Goel

Rajesh Rai
5 Min Read


Follow us on Google News


Follow The420.in on Google News

New Delhi: A United States district court has sought assistance from Indian courts to serve summons on National Security Advisor Ajit Doval and former Research and Analysis Wing chief Samant Goel. The Southern District Court of New York ordered that judicial documents be sent to India through an alternative legal process. However, Indian sources clarified that the American court order is not binding in India and should not be viewed as mandatory service of summons.

​According to the court order issued by Judge Katherine Polk Failla, the clerk of the court has been directed to send the necessary judicial documents via international mail or courier to three district courts in Delhi: Patiala House, Dwarka, and Tis Hazari. These courts have been requested to assist in delivering the summons to the respondents in the American civil lawsuit. The case stems from a civil suit filed by Gurpatwant Singh Pannun, founder of the pro-Khalistan group Sikhs for Justice, who has named Doval and Goel as respondents.

​Alternative Process Adopted Under the Hague Convention

​Court records show that an initial attempt was made to serve the summons through the standard route under the Hague Convention via India’s Central Authority, but that effort was not accepted. Following this, the US court permitted an alternative method of serving the summons under Article 19 of the Hague Convention and the provisions of India’s Code of Civil Procedure.

​The American court has requested cooperation from Indian judicial institutions to facilitate this process, prompting arrangements to send the documents to the three Delhi district courts. The step is aimed at advancing the legal proceedings in the pending civil lawsuit in the United States.

​Indian sources described the development as a routine and procedural step. They noted that a foreign court seeking assistance from Indian courts to serve summons does not amount to confirming the allegations or establishing legal liability for any individual. Similarly, the transmission of documents for serving summons cannot be construed as an acceptance of the lawsuit’s claims by the Indian government or the Indian judiciary.

​Summons Previously Sent Through the US Embassy

​Prior to this order, another route had been used to deliver the summons in the same matter. The US State Department had previously transmitted the summons through the Indian Embassy. At that time as well, it was clarified that the State Department’s action of delivering documents had no bearing on the merits of the case or the allegations made in it, and was merely part of the procedure to convey legal papers to the concerned parties.

​The current order represents the next step in that legal process, with the American court opting to serve the documents through India’s judicial system under the framework of international legal cooperation.

​Similar Summons Issued to Manmohan Singh in 2013

​This is not the first instance of Sikhs for Justice filing a lawsuit against Indian leaders in the United States. In 2013, a summons was also issued to former Prime Minister Manmohan Singh in a civil suit brought by the same organization. That lawsuit had alleged human rights violations linked to the 1984 anti-Sikh riots.

​In the present matter, Pannun has filed a civil suit in the US court, and the order seeking help from Indian courts to serve summons on Doval and Goel forms part of those proceedings. The order does not constitute any final ruling on the truth of the allegations, the liability of the respondents, or any potential legal outcome, as the US court’s action remains limited to the process of serving the summons.