The Calcutta High Court has reinstated criminal proceedings against former State Bank of India (SBI) Chief Manager and Relationship Manager Jyoti Ranjan Kanungo in a bank fraud and embezzlement case involving over Rs 164.99 crore. The court set aside a lower court order that had discharged Kanungo from the case, ruling that available evidence raises strong and grave suspicion of criminal conspiracy, cheating, and abuse of official position. In an order passed on November 12, Justice Uday Kumar directed the trial court to frame formal charges against Kanungo under appropriate legal provisions and proceed with a joint trial alongside other co-accused.
Lower Court Conducted Improper Mini-Trial
Justice Kumar sharply criticized the trial court’s approach, noting that while hearing the discharge application, it conducted a detailed evaluation of evidence as if holding a full trial. The High Court observed that drawing final conclusions on defence arguments and evidentiary credibility at the pre-charge stage is contrary to settled law. According to the order, the lower court failed to adequately consider crucial incriminating material and erred by isolating the role of a bank insider from the broader conspiracy involving private borrowers. The court further clarified that the evidentiary value of witness statements, internal audit findings, and departmental warnings must be tested during the trial rather than weighed prematurely under Section 239 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
Allegations of Fraudulent Credit Facilities
The case stems from a Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) probe into the alleged misappropriation of public funds from SBI. According to the agency, bank funds were diverted through unauthorized accounts, inter-company transactions were carried out without sufficient backing or security, and substantial outstanding dues were concealed through monthly signed statements. Investigators alleged that Kanungo actively facilitated M/s Shree Mahalaxmi Corporation Private Limited (SMCPL) in fraudulently securing massive credit facilities, resulting in a wrongful loss exceeding Rs 164.99 crore to SBI. Appearing for the CBI, Special Public Prosecutor Amajit De cited documentary evidence, audit trails, and system logs, arguing that the discrepancies in financial records were deliberate acts rather than routine administrative lapses.
Defence Claims Rejected at Discharge Stage
Lawyers representing Kanungo opposed the allegations, contending that he had no prior association with the borrower company or the co-accused, nor any motive to join a conspiracy. The defence argued that Kanungo processed credit appraisal and restructuring proposals strictly in accordance with institutional guidelines, and that these proposals were vetted and signed by senior bank officials, including the Deputy General Manager. However, the High Court held that these submissions were insufficient to discharge the accused at the preliminary stage. Holding offences under Section 13(2) read with Section 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, to be triable, the court allowed the CBI’s revision petition and restored Special CBI Case No. 02/22 against Kanungo. While the trial will now resume, the High Court noted that its order does not amount to a final determination of guilt, which will depend on evidence presented during the trial.
